Jun 9, 2009

Not so good cookies

There are a very few pre packaged cookies that I like and I am not a fan of store bought pre packaged cookie mixes and dough. I find them too sugary and synthetic to taste. Besides, it takes maybe 10 minutes more to prepare cookie dough from scratch as compared to opening a packet of pre mix.
Today, however, I broke my rule and decided to make cookies from a Duncan Hines Dark Chocolate Fudge cake mix. It had a recipe for making cookies by adding 2 eggs, 1 stick of butter and ¼ cup of brown sugar to the cake mix. I was skeptical of the recipe but followed the instructions and put the cookies in the oven.
Now because the main ingredients were that of a cake, my guess is there was too much baking powder and baking soda in it. It made the cookies expand a lot more than normal cookies. As a result my first batch of cookies was almost as big as a dessert plate. Also, the time specified on the box was way too much (14 – 16 minutes) for the cookies. If my oven light was not on I would have most certainly burnt them. It took about 8-10 minutes for the cookies to be done.
That can be a good thing when you have an impatient toddler hanging around the kitchen asking every two minutes, “Are they done yet?” They did look good too, all brown and chocolaty. Also, there wasn’t a lot of cleanup to do afterwards, just the mixing bowl and spoon.
So, what is the flip side? Well, for one the taste. As I said before, they were far too sweet and didn’t taste as good as the ones made at home. There was no texture to it and the chocolate flavor wasn’t intense even though I used the dark Chocolate Fudge flavor and added good quality chocolate chips for extra measure.
I will stick to my tried and tested kitchen sink cookies recipe.


  1. Hi Jaya.
    These cookies do not sound nearly as good as your homemade ones. I would much rather taste the ones YOU made:)

  2. Thanks. Any time you visit US let me know. :) I will make sure you get to taste them.

  3. You are a sweetheart :)
    I think I mightve just written the comment and not posted it..since it gave me some error..I mightve overlooked..
    neway..it was just praising that beautiful bread and also telling you that I had commented on your other blog which I realise now , you might not be active with...(weight loss entry)

  4. I agree, I find store bought cookie dough too sweet for my taste too....I rarely bake cookies and when I do mostly try and find healthier and low fat workarounds to baking them


Thank you for visiting my space. I miss my former editors, so any form of criticism/ appreciation is welcome. :)

Possibly related posts

Related Posts with Thumbnails